lecture v. discussion
discussions good for students and teacher
students: peer-instruction, engagement, self-expression
downside: can wander off what you'll be tested on
solution: objectives, terms, and discussion questions re-focus
teacher can stay focused on outcomes, objectives, but loses students
presentations
will work on next few days
will email updated assignment list
pre-midterm & midterm
review dates, imminence (apocalypse!)
possible topics for essay 2 (peersonal / professional topic)
look at models
1c. Science fiction is not just science but also fiction (see genres): How is Parable fictional in representational form, and how is its narrative romance? (instructor will lead)
after opening definitions of fiction page, ask difference from scripture
fiction page: > narrative, story-telling as problem-solving, Lauren's "shaping the future"
narrative: pp 3-5
dialogue: 6
pp. 62-3 mix
66 teach and entertain at same time
122 half antebellum revival and half sf 123 cities controlled by big companies old hat in sf [dystopia] 123-4 company-city subgenre Metropolis (film)
hard science fiction 11 hyperempathy syndrome [science fiction] esp. Wells's Law 105 TVs you go through . . . touchrings 144 Paracetco, Mother's drug
soft science fiction 26 soft sf, speculative fiction
17 latest Mars Mission [science, tech advance] 20-21 Mars as heaven, hell on earth (off-planet)
Review notes from last class on Revelation appeals
symbols & narratives; Nibiru; dystopia > millennium > utopia;
romance narrative
Apocalypse much easier to teach, for telling stories—human mind more receptive
Evolution enormously complex topic, human mind limited in comprehension
No purpose of telling you what to believe—-only lose if I try—students won't learn anything except that their teacher agrees or disagrees with them
neither story makes much difference in daily functioning but values?
—can't usually tell by looking at someone if they share your sense of how things came to be, or if they believe that dangerous nonsense that other people think or believe
people don't take sides unless you force them
most modern people functioning in modern world slip back and forth between both stories
like last class: one reality, so different people see different aspects or dimensions of that reality at different times or according to who they're with
So what do we do?
Not a scientist or a preacher, not a class in biology, geology, or history of science, nor in religious studies
Literature courses do many things, but esp. literary forms and cultural knowledge / discussion
three narratives of the future as three kinds of stories
stories both pleasure in imitating reality and instruction (how to act or not act)
66 teach and entertain at same time
Apocalypse suits limited attention span
plurality of Americans believe humans appear on Earth in past 10,000 years
6000-10,000 years
Matthew 24 34 Verily I say unto you, This generation shall not pass, till all these things be fulfilled.
"Last generation" appropriate to human time-cognition, mostly limited to a generation or so
Apocalypse flatters generational vanity idea around for 2000 + years historic failure but unfalsifiable--beleifs over facts
36 But of that day and hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels of heaven, but my Father only.
human stories compatible longer lives may counteract appeal
evolution: survival, adaptation, extinction evolution: change + continuity idea round for 150 years (though classical Greeks and Romans considered it]
inhuman, unfriendly time span universe 12-14 billion years, Earth 4.5 billion years, humans app. 200,000 years, civilization 3000 years? human life 30-90 years?
nature doesn't exactly care x God as pfather, Jesus as savior-hero, Mary as mother extinction as dinosaurs
Humans can't think very long, or collectively
characters talk about evolution, cultural cycles, repeated patterns in human history, present actions as having impact on continuous future ("Earthseed") rational analysis of human behavior in terms of change and adaptation Compare Parable to Genesis-Revelation as apocalypse narrative (or, more broadly, creation-apocalypse narrative) Also note other religious content (heroine's father a Baptist preacher) But differences:
122 half antebellum revival and half sf 123 cities controlled by big companies old hat in sf [dystopia] 123-4 company-city subgenre Metropolis (film)
hard science fiction 11 hyperempathy syndrome [science fiction] esp. Wells's Law 105 TVs you go through . . . touchrings 144 Paracetco, Mother's drug
soft science fiction 26 soft sf, speculative fiction
17 latest Mars Mission [science, tech advance] 20-21 Mars as heaven, hell on earth (off-planet)
creation-apocalypse narrative + evolutionary narrative 55 we can get ready, survive 55 like Jericho
creation-apocalypse narrative 9 Keith cf. mark of Cain 42 Moss girls--cf. nuclear family as Eden--apply to question reaction? 63 big live oak trees [Dad protects]
92 you disobeyed 144 Book of Revelation: Babylong the great is fallen . . . habitation of devils
evolutionary narrative 10 [Darwinian jungle] 12 adaptation, consequences of novelty 29 2025 intelligence = adaptability 31 selective breeding and selective dying . . . misdirected 50 island surrounded by sharks 56 cycle (business) 56 bubonic plague, world coming to end 56 changes 57 change as opportunity [creative destruction] 57 climate change 57 reading and studying 58 learn . . . to survive (adaptation) 58 live long enough to learn more 59 nothing is going to save us (x-romance narrative) contrast Revelation 59 cf. Pascal's wager (p. 8) 159 vultures
YA Dystopia? 4 heroic potential self, fantasy dream 5 different: multicultural 6 we can afford the stars: poetic, + prefigure 8 special knowledge: baptistery 8 go in a bunch, go armed [street culture] 13 care what he thinks about me [YA) 13 good how she delays IDing her god > chapter 2 [narrative[ 15 Deists . . . risk-taking 16 Jehovah = Zeus [fiction allows forbidden thoughts; just a story, + what character thinks, not author] 68 [YA] She was my best friend. Now she isn't. 89 [YA] waiting to be older 96 her kid, but not her kid [YA]
big difference: Bankole
Utopia
8 good old days (cf. Make America Great Again)
Dystopia
53 too many poor people
ch 4 33 incest [dystopia] 35 We help each other, and we don't steal [>utopia?] 36 fear and hate everyone [dystopia]
John 1; That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked upon, and our hands have handled, of the Word of life; 2 (For the life was manifested, and we have seen it, and bear witness, and shew unto you that eternal life, which was with the Father, and was manifested unto us;) 3 That which we have seen and heard declare we unto you, that ye also may have fellowship with us: and truly our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ. 4 And these things write we unto you, that your joy may be full. 5 This then is the message which we have heard of him, and declare unto you, that God is light, and in him is no darkness at all. 6 If we say that we have fellowship with him, and walk in darkness, we lie, and do not the truth: 7 But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the blood of Jesus Christ his Son cleanseth us from all sin. 8 If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. 9 If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. 10 If we say that we have not sinned, we make him a liar, and his word is not in us.
4 wall of fire? [symbols, images merge in dreams] 6 outside where things are dangerous and crazy (cf. Heaven in apocalypse, or garden of Eden in Genesis) 3 God = change 6 father’s god not my god 6 outside where things are dangerous and crazy (cf. Eden)
ch 2 8 good old days (cf. Make America Great Again) 8 [Pascal's wager] 9 Keith cf. mark of Cain 9 walled estates 10 [Darwinian jungle] 10 LA was better then 11 hyperempathy syndrome [science fiction] esp. Wells's Law 12 adaptation, consequences of novelty 14 John 1 & Acts 2 15 demographics 16 Job
Ch 3 17 latest Mars Mission [science, tech advance] 17 cost of water, water peddlers [sf] 18 x-gasoline [but no sense of solar, wind, etc.] 18 Window Wall TV [high tech] 19 new multisensory stuff [> SimStim] 19 police 20-21 Mars as heaven, hell on earth (off-planet) 20 space our future 22 church as community 23 new illegal drug [Fire] 24 no Job 24 expulsion from heaven [Astronaut dies on Mars mission] 24 Dad--I care what he thinks 24 What I believe 25 something my people need [prophecy] 25 intelligence adapts, single generation (evolution as social adaptation) 26 soft sf, speculative fiction
29 2025 intelligence = adaptability selective breeding . . . misdirected
ch 4 33 incest [dystopia] 35 We help each other, and we don't steal [>utopia?] 36 fear and hate everyone [dystopia] 36 combo Old Testament and West African 36 patriarchs 37 Dad tries to shield us 42 Moss girls--cf. nuclear family as Eden--apply to question reaction?
ch 5 47 rain six years ago . . . storm almost tropical 48 free water 50 all outsiders. Amy one of us 50 island surrounded by sharks 52 write to keep from going crazy 53 parents living with parents 53 take care of babies and cook [regression] 53 too many poor people 53 drug > set fires 54 tornadoes 54 immunizations 54 Donner is God > set country back 100 years 55 hit > hit > big hit [decline] 55 we can get ready, survive 55 like Jericho 56 cycle (business) > back to normal 56 bubonic plague, world coming to end 56 changes 57 change as opportunity 57 climate change; can't make climate change back 57 reading and studying, books on survival 58 learn . . . to survive (adaptation) 58 live long enough to learn more [continuous adaptation] 59 nothing is going to save us (x-romance narrative) . . . save ourselves 59 cf. Pascal's wager (p. 8)
ch. 6 61 Joanne told [YA] 61 don't talk about bad things [reverse magic] 62 learn to survive 62 your world is coming to an end [i.e. older generation perceive apocalypse] 62-3 good Af Am dad talk 63 big live oak trees [Dad protects] 63 problems building since long before born [sin or system?] 63 [analogy] like ignoring a fire 65 teach x scare, lose authority 66 teach and entertain at same time 66 obedience 66 Dad preached from Genesis 68 [YA] She was my best friend. Now she isn't. 68 Garden thieves 70 like Joanne--denial personified 73 gas-fueled cars 75 [collective] "I don't care about them! It's you I'm woorried about" . . . We can't think that way any more." 76 Live! Survive. 76 God is change . . . exists to be shaped playing business as usual while things gget worse and worse
ch. 7 78 Earthseed cf. evolution--islands seeded 79 so few computers 81 I hate [Dad's] decision, but maybe he's right. 82 tree . . . parents' shadows 82 cul-de-sac with a wall around it 83 big Anglo-Japanese cosmological station ont he moon detecting new worlds . . . .life-bearing 83 no one to talk to out there 83 extrasolar travel . . . out of shadow of parent world 84 exploration . . . profits, big future profits
ch. 8 87 get married and have babies? 88 Moss family x community effort 89 [YA] waiting to be older 90 submachine gun 92 you disobeyed
ch. 9 94 [epigraph] power struggles rams knocking heads [sexual dominance] 96 her kid, but not her kid [YA] 97 Keith new clothing, shoes empathy with Keith 98 stolen money, drug money, or worse
2026 101 [cultural evoluton] ongoing group adaptation adaptive function
ch. 10 103 survival, position, power 104 Dad gone to the college 105 TVs you go through . . . touchrings 105 Keith's reading adaptable; instructions for gadgets 106 Keith and Dad: he's you [evolution as continuity] 108 marrying Curtis and having a bunch of babies? 108 How did you survive? . . . 109 people all over the freeway coming from L.A. 110 Crazies. Paints . . . eat fire and kill rich people 112 Curtis, condoms identify Keith's body 114 cops "discover" evidence 115 hated Keith as much as I loved him . . . sociopathic hyperempathy as prevention
ch. 11 116 God is change 116 coming apart . . . community, families, members 118 Kagimoto, Stamm, Frampton KSF Olivar sea level, warming climate upper middle class, white, literate 119 desalination plant 119 privatized 119 dominate 119 formerly public land 119 early American company towns 120 they've got hundreds of me 120 get people in debt 121 denial 122 half antebellum revival and half sf 123 explosion, big crash, sudden chaos > bit by bit 123 cities controlled by big companies old hat in sf 123-4 company-city subgenre Metropolis (film) 124 Adaptable 125 Interconnected I'll adapt
ch 12 128 wants a future . . . like her parents' present 129 privatized cities? cheap labor and cheap land Dad didn't come home today 130 more squalor, more human remains, more feral dogs [decline] 131 a black man's arm 132 from Texas like my biological mother 133 [cannibalism] 134 sermon about perseverance the weak can overcome the strong
ch. 13 138 posing as a man 139 black and white x white enclave 143 fire drug 144 Paracetco, Mother's drug 144 Book of Revelation: Babylon the great is fallen . . . habitation of devils 147 Cory takes Dad's job; computer hookups
2027 151 questing, destiny
ch 14 153 burning 155 poverty made streets cleaner 159 vultures
Nehemiah 4.14 After I looked things over, I stood up and said to the nobles, the officials and the rest of the people, “Don’t be afraid of them. Remember the Lord, who is great and awesome, and fight for your families, your sons and your daughters, your wives and your homes.”
Lauren's Dad 58 "It's better to teach people than to scare them . . . . lose their fear . . . harder to scare them a second time" 58 "ways to entertain them and teach them at the same time" 59 "talk to them about classes, not Armageddon"
Another "sign" of apocalyptic thinking: "Decline" thinking . . . "Things are really getting bad out there." "The system can't take much more until everything falls apart."
example: compare beginning-middle-end of Parable with overall narrative of Bible: Eden, tree of life > fall, redemption of messiah, apocalypse > heaven, tree of life
Tree of life: Genesis 4.9 Rev. 2.7, 22.2
How does the re-appearance of the tree of life change the linear narrative of Genesis->Revelation?
Apocalyptic narrative literary appeal rich, spectacular imagery with lots of action--"sublime" reaction: beauty and fear vivid metaphors, analogies, and symbols--reader can take pleasure in interpreting, code-breaking, new applications--"I see the signs being fulfilled"; "I've identified the Antichrist!" compare narrative with "adventure story" or "romance narrative": stress builds until reader / character is saved by hero--danger / threat and rescue / salvation
Ideological / intellectual appeal stakes couldn't be higher, personally and globally--the fate of the world and the fate of the individual soul--dramatic; near-future story happens within human time scale--"I come quickly."--"We are the last generation."--therefore personalized, made immediate (contrast evolution's time scale) also, time is linear, helping story-telling or narrative
Temptation to keep working on it is great . . . . This is the kind of literary analysis we all do, but mostly with secular texts, added attraction: the content matters to a lot of people--or at least recognizable Quizzes: obvious that people carry around bits of knowledge, attitudes determined by Genesis-Revelation
No way our class can do it all--summer school has to keep moving Keep the big view and be adaptable Primary Objectives—Narratives & Visions of the Future
1.
To identify, describe, and criticize
narratives or
stories humans tell about the future:
a.
Apocalyptic
b.
Evolutionary
c.
Alternative
apocalypse = linear narrative, time has beginning and end Rev. 1.8 Alpha and Omega Rev. 22.13 I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the end, the first and the last.
evolution = cyclical narrative, circle . . . (natural time patterns, like seasons, day, year)
Literary topics: objective 3. Is the future "written" (i. e., set, fixed, programmed, and usually apocalyptic) or "being written" ("open-ended" and usually evolutionary)? In Parable, is the future written or being written? What is attractiveness to readers of apocalyptic theme?
Cultural topics:
Extend scene in
Parable to contemporary world of unwinnable
wars, unpayable debt, growing gaps between rich and poor
What current trends culminate in the nightmare world
of Parable?—
hope or horror at Literature of the Future?
How to react to "the coming anarchy?"
Arm or disarm?
Engage society or retreat from it? 4 wall of fire? 6 outside where things are dangerous and crazy (cf. Heaven in apocalypse, or garden of Eden in Genesis) 6 father’s god not my god 18-19 Mars as heaven, hell on earth (off-planet) 59 Dad preached from Genesis 82 you disobeyed old world has to be destroyed to create new 55 "I think your world is coming to an end . . . ." 73 a tree cannot grow in its parents' shadows
death is evolution's dirty little secret; one other dirty little secret: sex
Genesis-Revelation narrative: World / order is created, is lost > restored, redeemed
Evolution (or at least variations from Genesis-Revelation) 3 God = change 25 intelligence adapts, single generation (evolution as social adaptation) 51 no one's going to save us; save ourselves 52 survive 55 "The problems we have now have been building since long before your were born." 111 adaptable and interconnected
Lauren's Dad 58 "It's better to teach people than to scare them . . . . lose their fear . . . harder to scare them a second time" 58 "ways to entertain them and teach them at the same time" 59 "talk to them about classes, not Armageddon"
51 Nothing is going to save us. If we don't save ourselves, we're dead.
|